Amen to this!
Some people get very fussed over people who don't go to church often.
I've always thought that it's better to just welcome them when they do come, and trust that God will lead them to be there when they need to be and lead the rest of us to evangelise via our regular relationships.
This article takes it a bit further, and asks what the regular attending holy-joes can learn from the special-event-sallies about what really matters.
Work with what you have, not what you'd like to have.
Food for thought.
Wednesday, 14 January 2015
Thursday, 1 January 2015
Proper texts to Improper tunes are still Improper!
Thanks (or not) to the folks at Chant Café for this great example of how to do things Improperly!
What you get if you click is a page titled "An Advent Calendar of Hymn Tune Introits - Liturgical Year 2015".
It has one short scriptural verse in English - which is it the Entrance Antiphon for the day. No copyright acknowledgement to the scriptural translation or versifier. No clarification that it's for the 2014/2015 liturgical year. (Remember the new Mass - introduced in "Advent 2011" - which was December 2010 in New Zealand and December 2011 in lots of other placed. This sheet seems to take the opposite approach to naming liturgical years - highlighting perfectly why the abbreviated approach isn't good enough.)
For weekday masses, I do think that a sung one verse entrance "antiphon" makes sense: it unifies people, introduces elements of rhythm and melody which are spiritually important for some people, and makes the overall tone of the gathering spiritual. And the Propers make great texts for this - especially because a weekday congregation is usually a lot more familiar with scripture, so will likely make the link between the short snippet and the wider piece which it comes from.
But the same tune, every day, for every single one? I cannot see how that can work - unless the underlying tune is so blandly lit-muzak that it doesn't highlight any particular phrase at all! Liturgically Proper, yes. But musically not at all the proper thing to be doing. If you're going to sing propers, then do it properly by puting at least some thought into choosing tunes that support the meaning of the text.
Reading some more:
Randomly-selected hymnody? Does anyone really do that any more? Really? All pastoral musicians I know at least choose seasonally appropriate hymns based on the index of their hymnal. For Sundays, most spend substantial time with the readings and other texts of the day, looking for materials that fit with them and will work with the particular community.
And I wonder if CC would care to explain exactly how the Proper text (remember, snippets of scripture presented out of context) are more spiritually beneficial than a scriptural hymn with several verses to provide "space" for context. There's a whiff of magic thinking here.
Final Shopping Day for Advent Weekdays in the Hymn Tune Propers Emporium
If you or a Pastor or Music Director you know would like to do something liturgically special for Advent Weekdays here at the last moment, just click here, print out as many copies as you need for your daily Mass crowd, place them on a table where they will be noticed, and sing these versified Entrance Antiphons at the beginning of daily Mass. Any Long Meter tune that is familiar in your parish will work fine.
What you get if you click is a page titled "An Advent Calendar of Hymn Tune Introits - Liturgical Year 2015".
It has one short scriptural verse in English - which is it the Entrance Antiphon for the day. No copyright acknowledgement to the scriptural translation or versifier. No clarification that it's for the 2014/2015 liturgical year. (Remember the new Mass - introduced in "Advent 2011" - which was December 2010 in New Zealand and December 2011 in lots of other placed. This sheet seems to take the opposite approach to naming liturgical years - highlighting perfectly why the abbreviated approach isn't good enough.)
For weekday masses, I do think that a sung one verse entrance "antiphon" makes sense: it unifies people, introduces elements of rhythm and melody which are spiritually important for some people, and makes the overall tone of the gathering spiritual. And the Propers make great texts for this - especially because a weekday congregation is usually a lot more familiar with scripture, so will likely make the link between the short snippet and the wider piece which it comes from.
But the same tune, every day, for every single one? I cannot see how that can work - unless the underlying tune is so blandly lit-muzak that it doesn't highlight any particular phrase at all! Liturgically Proper, yes. But musically not at all the proper thing to be doing. If you're going to sing propers, then do it properly by puting at least some thought into choosing tunes that support the meaning of the text.
Reading some more:
"The Hymn Tune Propers Project provides an easy first step away from randomly-selected hymnody and towards the use of the proper liturgical texts of the Mass. The proper texts are spiritually beneficial for Catholics ... "
Randomly-selected hymnody? Does anyone really do that any more? Really? All pastoral musicians I know at least choose seasonally appropriate hymns based on the index of their hymnal. For Sundays, most spend substantial time with the readings and other texts of the day, looking for materials that fit with them and will work with the particular community.
And I wonder if CC would care to explain exactly how the Proper text (remember, snippets of scripture presented out of context) are more spiritually beneficial than a scriptural hymn with several verses to provide "space" for context. There's a whiff of magic thinking here.
Friday, 26 December 2014
Stealing other people's music - or pictures - is not cool
One of the (very small number of) interesting-minded conservative-Catholic bloggers that I sometimes read recently got pinged for image copyright violations.
Not so seemly that she then posted complaining about the complainers, rather than just quietly cleaning up her act.
The post is now gone from the website, so I'm guessing that the commenters gave a fairly sharp reminder about the commandments in general and Thou Shalt Not Steal in particular. Unfortunately RSS feed-readers mean that many people will see it anyway. A good reminder to always, always think before you post.
Copyright law is hard. It's difficult for musicians and liturgists. Most of us break the law at least sometimes, usually for "good" purposes that don't benefit us personally. I have a lot of sympathy for the struggle. I believe in being honest, but even so I take liberties sometimes.
But systematically stealing other people's images to use on your own posts is Just Not On. The worker is worthy of their wages, and all that.
Not so seemly that she then posted complaining about the complainers, rather than just quietly cleaning up her act.
The post is now gone from the website, so I'm guessing that the commenters gave a fairly sharp reminder about the commandments in general and Thou Shalt Not Steal in particular. Unfortunately RSS feed-readers mean that many people will see it anyway. A good reminder to always, always think before you post.
Copyright law is hard. It's difficult for musicians and liturgists. Most of us break the law at least sometimes, usually for "good" purposes that don't benefit us personally. I have a lot of sympathy for the struggle. I believe in being honest, but even so I take liberties sometimes.
But systematically stealing other people's images to use on your own posts is Just Not On. The worker is worthy of their wages, and all that.
Saturday, 13 December 2014
All musical instruments have a place in church
A fact worth remembering:
Psalm 150 mentions all 4 classes of musical instruments - strings, woodwind, brass & percussion. There is no Biblical justification for banning anything that's used to the glory of God.
Tuesday, 25 November 2014
Congregations, Choirs and Soloists
Ran across this website while searching - the guy's home page is broken but the sub pages all work.
Some very well put thoughts about the role of musicians and soloists,:
Some very well put thoughts about the role of musicians and soloists,:
"... the assembly in the pews is the principal choir at Liturgy."
"The job of all musicians, be they instrumentalists or singers, is to help facilitate the “full, active and conscious participation of the faithful.”
" Soloists ... have the special ministry of delivering a piece of music ... in such a way that the assembly is inspired, encouraged, indeed, compelled, to participate in the “prayer” of the solo ... The intention of the solo is to use the inherent artistry of the piece and the prayerful talent of the musician to lift the level of engagement of the listeners from that of passive observation, to active participation."
"The focus for a moment may be on the soloist who is offering the music, but the clear and authentic intent of the offering is to deftly channel the energy directed momentarily at the performer, to the prayerful content of the music, and then, in turn, to galvanize that prayerful, spiritual energy into a communal experience that transcends the personal performance of the soloist."
Wednesday, 19 November 2014
Why choosing music for church should be a shared responsibility
An interesting post and comments on PrayTell.
From the quotes there, the American bishops anticipate that music selection is done by a committee which has received clear delegation from the pastor.
But most musical directors (at least the ones who post on internet forums) dislike that: they would rather be a committee of one, they would never dream of letting ignoramuses choose music, believe no one else has the knowledge and skills etc.
Thankfully a few of the commentators there are more reflective. The best is this one:
It seems to me that
- even if you are a professional musical director, vastly more qualified in both liturgy and music than your pastor, choir, musicians and liturgy committee, and
- even if you have all musical decision making authority delegated to you from the pastor
the best way to use this authority is the same way a wise parish-priest uses his authority. Sparingly and with lots of consultation. Ideally in way that your people don't even know that you're exercising authority.
Why?
On a very personal level, for reasons of self-protection: The best way to encourage a pastor to change his mind about your role and his delegated authority is a stream of people complaining to him about the music. If people cannot give you input, and see that it is taken notice of sometimes, then you can guarantee they will make their feelings known. If that happens, then best case, the pastor will not let you make the choices any more. Worst case, he'll fire you. Meaningfully listening to other people and developing respectful relationships with them is your best protection against this.
On a more theological level wise stewardship of a community's musical resoures requires making the best use of all the gifts available to you. That means need to engaging people and make them enthusiastic about working with you. That won't happen if you're autocratic. What's more you have both human and theologcial weaknesses and blind-spots, no matter how talented and well educated you are. There will be times when you simply run out of inspiration, when you miss the implications of a scripture message - or when a crisis in your life means that you have to step back and focus on your own family priorities for a few days. Biology means you can only see things from the perspective for your own gender and ethnic group. This means that you need a team to ensure that "the show goes on" and that the message fully reflects the Gospel.
Educationally developing the spiritual lives, liturgical knowledge, musical skill and leadership gifts of the people in your choirs, ensembles and music teams may or may not be part of your formal job description. But I've never yet seen a parish where it wasn't expected, at least informally. If you let other people take part in your decision-making processes, then you will be present when teachable moments, times when you can share liturgical-music knowledge and skill will happen naturally, - people won't even realise that they are learning. But if you work alone, they won't happen - and you won't be there when they happen in the liturgy group meeting or school staffroom.
This goes way beyond the musical skill development that you can share in choir practise - it's about sharing liturgical and practical wisdom based on both Church teaching and your own experience.
And your voice will be most effective if you are seen as a warm and friendly as well as wise and liturgio-musical: A music director's primary role is relational, not melodic.
From the quotes there, the American bishops anticipate that music selection is done by a committee which has received clear delegation from the pastor.
But most musical directors (at least the ones who post on internet forums) dislike that: they would rather be a committee of one, they would never dream of letting ignoramuses choose music, believe no one else has the knowledge and skills etc.
Thankfully a few of the commentators there are more reflective. The best is this one:
All too often, the question of “Who picks the music?” is answered in terms of power. More properly, it should be answered in terms of gifts. Who knows the repertoire and skills of the musical leaders? Who knows the singing abilities of the community? Who knows the resources at hand? Who knows how to blend worship into a seamless event (rather than a stop-start mishmash)?
It seems to me that
- even if you are a professional musical director, vastly more qualified in both liturgy and music than your pastor, choir, musicians and liturgy committee, and
- even if you have all musical decision making authority delegated to you from the pastor
the best way to use this authority is the same way a wise parish-priest uses his authority. Sparingly and with lots of consultation. Ideally in way that your people don't even know that you're exercising authority.
Why?
On a very personal level, for reasons of self-protection: The best way to encourage a pastor to change his mind about your role and his delegated authority is a stream of people complaining to him about the music. If people cannot give you input, and see that it is taken notice of sometimes, then you can guarantee they will make their feelings known. If that happens, then best case, the pastor will not let you make the choices any more. Worst case, he'll fire you. Meaningfully listening to other people and developing respectful relationships with them is your best protection against this.
On a more theological level wise stewardship of a community's musical resoures requires making the best use of all the gifts available to you. That means need to engaging people and make them enthusiastic about working with you. That won't happen if you're autocratic. What's more you have both human and theologcial weaknesses and blind-spots, no matter how talented and well educated you are. There will be times when you simply run out of inspiration, when you miss the implications of a scripture message - or when a crisis in your life means that you have to step back and focus on your own family priorities for a few days. Biology means you can only see things from the perspective for your own gender and ethnic group. This means that you need a team to ensure that "the show goes on" and that the message fully reflects the Gospel.
Educationally developing the spiritual lives, liturgical knowledge, musical skill and leadership gifts of the people in your choirs, ensembles and music teams may or may not be part of your formal job description. But I've never yet seen a parish where it wasn't expected, at least informally. If you let other people take part in your decision-making processes, then you will be present when teachable moments, times when you can share liturgical-music knowledge and skill will happen naturally, - people won't even realise that they are learning. But if you work alone, they won't happen - and you won't be there when they happen in the liturgy group meeting or school staffroom.
This goes way beyond the musical skill development that you can share in choir practise - it's about sharing liturgical and practical wisdom based on both Church teaching and your own experience.
And your voice will be most effective if you are seen as a warm and friendly as well as wise and liturgio-musical: A music director's primary role is relational, not melodic.
Wednesday, 5 November 2014
Let us Go to the Altar of God
I found this while I was searching for examples of possible hymns for Sunday.
Most of the versions that YouTube gave me first were just horrid. And then this appeared - with only 176 views.
The announcements at the beginning are weird - and must be stranger still if you're sitting in the church being welcomes by a disembodied voice. But skip to about 1:25, and enjoy the hymn.
Most of the versions that YouTube gave me first were just horrid. And then this appeared - with only 176 views.
The announcements at the beginning are weird - and must be stranger still if you're sitting in the church being welcomes by a disembodied voice. But skip to about 1:25, and enjoy the hymn.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)